After serving its Newark, New Jersey community for over six decades, Grace Temple Baptist Church found itself in need of repairs. Church leaders paid over $32,000 for a new roof, only to experience leaks just two days after completion.
After more than a year of delays, the church turned to CBS News New York Investigates, leading to a resolution.
The Church’s Struggle with a Faulty Roof
A Historic Church: Founded in 1963 by Rev. John L. McClain, the church has long been a cornerstone of the community.
The Roof Replacement:
- In June 2023, church leaders signed a contract with Home Genius Exteriors for a $32,000+ roof replacement.
- Just two days after the job was completed, leaks appeared in the ceiling.
- Church members, including Deacon John Titus, who uses a wheelchair, had to navigate around water damage for more than a year and a half.
“When people come in, it’s an embarrassment to our church, our community, and our Christ,” said Rev. Keith Oden.
Repeated Calls for Repairs:
- The company sent multiple crews but failed to identify the leak.
- By January 2025, the company became less responsive, with missed appointments and unanswered calls.
- Frustrated, the church contacted CBS News New York Investigates.
CBS News Steps In – And the Contractor Responds
Investigative reporter Mahsa Saeidi reached out to Home Genius Exteriors for answers.
Company’s Response:
- Co-founder Austin Killian admitted, “We definitely made mistakes. We are going to solve this problem.”
- Within 48 hours, company crews returned and located the leak—originating from the steeple, not the newly installed roof.
- The company sealed the leak temporarily and committed to a permanent fix.
Company’s Official Statement:
“After thorough inspections, we determined the leak was not related to our work. However, we are covering the cost of a specialty contractor to replace their damaged copper spire at no charge.” – Home Genius Exteriors
Final Resolution: Who’s Paying for the Repairs?
Disputed Claims:
- Home Genius Exteriors claimed a previous contractor damaged the copper spire.
- Rev. Oden refuted this, stating:“We’ve never had any work done on the steeple at any point in our church’s existence.”
The Final Fix:
- Rev. Oden hired a specialty contractor to replace the steeple.
- Home Genius Exteriors agreed to cover the costs for the permanent repairs.
