U.S. President Donald Trump’s announcement of a plan to “take over” Gaza and turn it into a “Riviera of the Middle East” has sparked international outrage. This proposal, which suggests U.S. ownership of the Palestinian territory, has led to strong reactions from global leaders, human rights organizations, and civilians. While some Israeli officials see this as a strategic move, Palestinian leaders and many world powers have condemned it as a violation of international law.
Palestinian Leaders Strongly Oppose the Plan
Palestinian Authority (PA) President Mahmoud Abbas rejected Trump’s proposal, calling it a serious violation of Palestinian rights. He emphasized that true peace in the region can only come through the establishment of an independent Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital. Hamas, which governs Gaza, also strongly opposed the plan, labeling it a “crime against humanity.” The militant group warned that any attempt to implement the proposal could destabilize the fragile ceasefire agreement currently in place.
Concerns from Israeli Hostage Families
Families of Israeli hostages still held in Gaza have expressed deep concerns over Trump’s announcement. They fear that the plan could disrupt ongoing negotiations between Israel and Hamas for the release of hostages. Ronen Neutra, the father of an Israeli soldier killed in the October 7 Hamas attack, reminded world leaders that securing the safe return of hostages should be the priority before making political moves.
Middle Eastern Countries Reject the Proposal
Many Middle Eastern nations, including key U.S. allies, have firmly opposed Trump’s suggestion.
- Egypt: The Egyptian government stressed that a two-state solution is the only viable path to peace.
- Jordan: King Abdullah II rejected any attempts to annex Palestinian land or displace its people.
- Saudi Arabia: Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman stated that Saudi Arabia would not normalize ties with Israel unless a Palestinian state is created.
These countries fear that forced displacement of Palestinians could cause further instability in the region.
Global Powers Condemn the Move
Nations beyond the Middle East have also expressed their disapproval:
- France: The French government called forced displacement of Palestinians a major violation of international law.
- United Kingdom: British Prime Minister Keir Starmer reaffirmed his support for a two-state solution, emphasizing that Palestinians must be allowed to rebuild their homes.
- Russia & China: Both countries issued statements supporting a Palestinian state.
Israel’s Stance on the Proposal
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu stood beside Trump as he made the announcement but has not directly endorsed a two-state solution. His government, which leans far-right, has shown little interest in pursuing peace talks with Palestinians.
Possible Motivations Behind Trump’s Announcement
Experts suggest that Trump’s bold statement could be part of a broader strategy. Dr. Sanam Vakil from Chatham House believes Trump’s goal might be to shift global discussions on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. He could also be trying to strengthen his support among pro-Israel voters in the U.S. and assist Netanyahu in ongoing ceasefire negotiations.
Additionally, Trump may see this as a bargaining tool in potential Israel-Saudi peace talks. If Saudi Arabia normalizes ties with Israel in exchange for halting annexation, it could be seen as a diplomatic victory.
Trump’s proposal to take over Gaza has been met with global criticism, particularly from Palestinian leaders and international allies. Many see it as a violation of international law and a threat to regional stability. With ongoing hostage negotiations and a fragile ceasefire, world leaders are urging a focus on diplomatic solutions rather than controversial territorial claims. The situation remains highly sensitive, and any misstep could lead to increased tensions in the Middle East.
