The Creed movies have done a remarkable job of breathing new life into the Rocky franchise, delivering a fresh perspective, compelling characters, and intense boxing action. With three critically acclaimed films already released and Michael B. Jordan expressing interest in directing Creed IV, the franchise seems poised for a long run.
However, while Rocky was an undeniable classic, its multiple sequels ultimately hurt the franchise’s legacy. If Creed follows the same trajectory, it risks diluting its impact and overextending its welcome. Here’s why Creed should avoid the pitfalls of Rocky and end on a high note.
Why Creed Doesn’t Need as Many Movies as Rocky
The first three Creed movies have told a cohesive and well-developed story, charting Adonis Creed’s rise, fall, and redemption:
- Creed (2015) introduced Adonis as a promising young fighter stepping out of his father’s shadow.
- Creed II (2018) tested his resolve and forced him to confront his past, particularly Ivan Drago’s legacy.
- Creed III (2023) explored his personal growth and life after boxing, while also introducing a powerful antagonist in Damian Anderson (Jonathan Majors).
With Adonis already nearing the end of his career, Creed IV is expected to see him transition into a mentor role—possibly training his daughter Amara, Felix Chavez, or even Viktor Drago.
Where Creed Should Stop
While passing the torch makes sense, continuing the franchise indefinitely would be a mistake. The Rocky franchise overstayed its welcome, producing six movies—two of which (Rocky IV and Rocky V) were heavily criticized.
If Creed follows suit, it could risk:
- Repetitive storylines (how many redemption arcs can one franchise have?)
- Losing emotional weight (each sequel would lower the stakes)
- Damaging Adonis’ legacy (turning a well-crafted character into a trope)
Even if the franchise transitions to Amara Creed, another trilogy should be the maximum to avoid creative exhaustion.
How Rocky’s Multiple Sequels Hurt Its Legacy
While Rocky remains an undisputed classic, the franchise’s later films gradually diminished its impact.
| Movie | Release Year | Rotten Tomatoes Critics Score | Audience Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rocky | 1976 | 93% | 69% |
| Rocky II | 1979 | 70% | 82% |
| Rocky III | 1982 | 65% | 74% |
| Rocky IV | 1985 | 39% | 79% |
| Rocky V | 1990 | 32% | 31% |
| Rocky Balboa | 2006 | 78% | 76% |
Where Rocky Went Wrong
- Declining Quality:
- Rocky II and Rocky III were solid, but they didn’t match the emotional depth of the original.
- Rocky IV was iconic for Ivan Drago, but its over-the-top style bordered on parody.
- Rocky V was universally panned, seen as an unnecessary and forced sequel.
- Repetitive Plots:
- Each movie followed Rocky facing a bigger, badder opponent, making the fights feel predictable.
- The underdog redemption formula became overused, lessening its emotional impact.
- Rocky’s Character Became Overextended:
- By Rocky V, Rocky felt like a caricature rather than a fully developed character.
- Rocky Balboa tried to course-correct, but it was too little, too late.
If Creed continues for too long, it risks falling into the same pattern—recycling old rivalries or struggling to find new angles.
The Smartest Path for Creed IV and Beyond
What Creed IV Should Do
- Shift Adonis Creed into a mentor role (without forcing another comeback fight).
- Introduce a fresh, compelling protagonist (Amara Creed, Felix Chavez, or Viktor Drago).
- Keep the story personal and grounded rather than escalating into unrealistic conflicts.
What Creed Should Avoid
- Bringing Adonis back into the ring for another fight (this would be repetitive).
- Over-relying on Rocky callbacks (the franchise needs to stand on its own).
- Dragging the franchise beyond a logical conclusion (quality over quantity).
